Two stories are told. The first deals with the Binewski children's constant viscious struggle against each other, but espeically against Arty as he develops his own cult: Artuism. Artuism involves members having their limbs amputated so that they can end up just like Arty. Arty battles his siblings to maintain control over them. Mundane aspects of their lives, such as ticket sales, can invoke battles.
The second story involves Oly's daughter, Miranda. Miranda has a special defect of her own, a small tail, that she wants to have cut off. She goes to one Ms. Mary Lick, a wealthy woman who pays poor attractive women to get operations to disfigure themselves so that they may live to their potential instead of being sex objects to men. Oly's plan is to stop Lick and protect her daughter.
There has been no movie made of Geek Love as of yet, but it is rumored that director Tim Burton wants to eventually sign on with the project.